joinee_doug, on 22 March 2012 - 02:50 PM, said:
I'm glad you said that, David...I'd been pondering it for a long time, based on the "Good story / Dull book" quandary. In the meantime, I read a more fun-sized account (150 pages or so) of Alexander Selkirk, generally thought to be inspiration for RC. Great story, mostly focused on the circumstances w/o having always to set the scene or go to the flashback, etc.
(I think it was aimed at the young adult reader (i.e. teenage) which was fine - I've kind of cooled on the Big Important Biography genre for now - I realized that for the most part, I didn't want or need to know everything about what a person did or was like...

)
Selkirk's story is more interesting that Defoe's rewriting of it. Even the lecturer who taught it to me described it as an 'intensely boring' novel - it was set on our syllabus because of the reputation that it's gained as being the first English prose novel and even that claim can be picked apart if you look at it closely.
Joinee Hathorn, on 22 March 2012 - 09:19 PM, said:
...Coral Island is much better.
I couldn't agree more, I loved Coral Island.
Finished
The Interesting Narrative of Olaudah Equiano this week which I actually really, really enjoyed. It's for the same Islands and Oceans Literature unit that I read Crusoe for but it was really interesting and very readable.
Now moving on to Tim Winton's
Breath for the same course. I'm about 100 pages in so far but just flying through it. He's a really interesting author and I find it odd that he's never flourished here (my lecturer is Australian and says that he's quite big in Australasia but has never had much luck outside - I'd certainly never heard of him). Really beautiful depictions of water and he knows how to keep a reader hooked. Plus it's always nice to read something that's very modern after a long stream of classics.
This post has been edited by GJ Dandy David: 30 March 2012 - 12:22 PM
No one could make a greater mistake than he who did nothing because he could do only a little - Edmund Burke